1799 Baldwin Avenue: A Serene Maui Sanctuary

Tucked between the charming towns of Makawao and Paia, 1799 Baldwin Avenue offers the kind of tranquility and privacy that feels increasingly rare on Maui. Set on over four lush acres in Sunnyside, this stunning estate is more than just a home—it’s a place where life slows down, natural beauty abounds, and every detail has been carefully considered.

From the moment you arrive, the estate unfolds like a dream. The long driveway, surrounded by verdant landscapes, draws you into a world where modern elegance meets timeless island charm. The main residence, a thoughtfully designed 4,000-square-foot home, immediately impresses with its craftsmanship. Rare O’hi’a lehua hardwood floors run throughout the interiors, complemented by elegant trims, custom lighting, and architectural touches that seamlessly blend sophistication with comfort.

Inside, the home feels airy and connected to the land. Large windows flood the space with natural light and frame views of the surrounding countryside. The open layout invites you to move effortlessly between the living, dining, and kitchen areas, creating a flow that is ideal for both quiet evenings and lively gatherings. The kitchen, anchored by high-end finishes and plenty of space for cooking or hosting, feels like the heart of the home—a warm, inviting space where conversations flow as easily as the coffee.

The beauty of this property lies in its thoughtful details. The foundation has been reinforced with structural I-beams, and the wildfire-resistant aluminum roof—installed in 2017 with a transferable 50-year warranty—ensures both safety and peace of mind. These touches reflect a home that was not just built but crafted, with an enduring quality that will be appreciated for generations.

The estate’s exterior is just as impressive as what lies inside. Step onto the west-facing lawn at sunset, where the sky is painted in hues of gold and crimson—a view you’ll want to savor night after night. Meander through the terraced front yard or take a seat under the charming gazebo, its ambient lighting creating a magical space to unwind or entertain. The grounds feel like a private park, a place where kids can run freely, friends can gather, and quiet moments are spent listening to the gentle sounds of nature.For guests or family members, the separate cottage offers a private, fully equipped retreat, complete with its own kitchen, bath, and laundry facilities. Whether hosting extended family, visiting friends, or creating space for an office or studio, this additional structure provides flexibility and charm.The property also offers a modern art studio, perfect for creative pursuits, as well as a spacious 3-car garage with ample storage. Every inch of this estate has been thoughtfully planned to provide comfort, utility, and beauty.But perhaps the most enchanting feature of 1799 Baldwin Avenue is its gardens. A true paradise for gardeners, the property flourishes with Meyer lemons, oranges, coffee, bananas, and more. A thriving vegetable garden beautifully complements the vibrant orchard. Whether you dream of cultivating fresh produce, designing floral arrangements, or simply enjoying the bounty of your own property, this estate offers an endless connection to the land.

"One of my favorite aspects of this property is its location—it’s situated in my favorite spot on the island, offering expansive bi-coastal views from an estate on Baldwin Avenue, just below Lumeria. Its proximity to Paia town, the Maui Country Club, Ho‘okipa, and all the North Shore’s incredible wind and water sports makes it truly unmatched,” Sam Utley, RB-23179, Island Sotheby’s Internationa Realty listing agent. 

The location is another highlight. Surrounded by farmland and grazing land, the estate feels completely private—no visible neighbors in sight—yet it’s just 20 minutes to town. Nearby, the Lumeria retreat center offers accommodations for visiting friends and family, while the Cycle to the Sun race route and Maui’s incredible hiking trails are close enough for spontaneous adventures. Paia, with its boutique shops, vibrant dining scene, and world-renowned windsurfing beaches, is minutes away, offering a perfect balance of seclusion and connection.

Whether you’re hosting sunset dinners on the lawn, enjoying the sound of Nene birds at sunrise, or escaping to the gazebo for a moment of quiet reflection, this home offers a rare blend of versatility and charm. It’s a place to entertain, grow, create, and truly live.

"Beyond its stunning features and prime location, the sellers have shared what makes this property truly special to them—offering a glimpse into the unique lifestyle it provides. The owners of 1799 Baldwin Avenue describe it as a true sanctuary, filled with thoughtful details and natural beauty. They love the warm feel of the Ohi‘a wood floors, the practical yet elegant lighting, and the sense of calm that comes with entering the driveway. At the same time, the land, free from chemical residues, thrives with just the right amount of Haiku rain to support lush greenery, fruit trees, and a vegetable garden. Unique touches like custom-grown trees, hidden cabinetry, and occasional visits from Nene geese add even more charm to this exceptional estate.” Mino McLean, RB-21623, Island Sotheby’s Internationa Realty listing agent.

1799 Baldwin Avenue is more than a home; it’s a retreat, a sanctuary, and a legacy property waiting to be enjoyed for years to come. For more information or to schedule a private showing, contact Island Sotheby’s International Realty.